Ethical (Philosophi...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Ethical (Philosophical) Considerations

14 Posts
7 Users
20 Likes
243 Views
Posts: 53
(@xyzabc)
Trusted Member
Joined: 4 years ago
 
I remember once Ernst mentioning that scientific accuracy in astrology was something around the 80% mark. I don't remember the exact figure, but it was low enough that I was quite horrified. 
What makes astrologers believe that they know, without a shred of doubt? I think astrologers should be open about the fallibility of this art/science, without the fear of losing money or clients. I think there is much to be learnt from it as long as we treat it as a partial-truth, for it is nothing more than that.
 
Even if the accuracy becomes higher, I can't help but think that astrology is a cynical art/science as it is based on the view that things don't change, people don't change. But astrologers are not God, they do not know everything, they do not determine fate, and there is divine will over and above all this. Internalizing this will not only temper any extreme view, but render this question of "should I reveal all, or should I shield people" irrelevant.

Reply
Ernst Wilhelm
Posts: 3502
Admin
(@ernst)
Member
Joined: 12 years ago

Its really a matter of saying what is helpful and not saying what is harmful. There are NO firm rules to this. You have to have the sensitivity to do this. Once I had a client come, I said, you have been to astrologers before? She said yes, and I said, they ALL said you would be wealthy? And she said yes. And I said, when you said, No, i am not wealthy, they said, You certainly will be one day. She said, that is correct, they all said I would be very wealthy one day. And I said, Well, I am here to tell you that you will NEVER be wealthy.

This may seem like an inappropriate thing to say. However, upon my saying this, she laughed in relief and said, oh, thank you so much for saying that! All these astrologers said I should be wealthy and I don't even care about money and I was thinking I was doing something wrong! Now I know I am living my life just right! 

haha. Readings are so funny sometimes.  

Reply
Posts: 53
(@xyzabc)
Trusted Member
Joined: 4 years ago

@ernst 

But if this person changes her mind on wealth, wouldn't an emphatic word like "NEVER" become the cause of an unnecessary issue or a deep block and suppression that lingers, which could have been avoided with a different approach?

Of course, one could argue a reading is just "for the moment", but human mind doesn't work like that. People remember things said in the past. Moreover, astrologers are not really advising people to take their readings as being "for the moment", but as being final.

Reply
Ernst Wilhelm
Posts: 3502
Admin
(@ernst)
Member
Joined: 12 years ago

In that case, she has lots of astrologers saying she WILL be rich so she can easily brush me off as a failure. 

I would not say that to a person who had not had those predictions, that's why I asked her what the other astrologers said. 

Reply
Posts: 792
(@staffan)
Noble Member
Joined: 2 years ago

I´m revisiting the outer planets course, and in that Ernst gives the advice to use the outer planets to gloss over some more difficult predictions, when you realize that the person isn´t prepared for to hear them. It´s in the first audio.

Or... "gloss over"... Balance the more concrete prediction with a little more longterm and spiritual considerations.

Staffan

Reply
Page 2 / 2
Share: