Hello Ernst,
I was asked by someone who has financial problems if they need to sell their flat that they own. They dont want to sell it but may be forced to do it.
There are succes or failure indications like "the rising sign is a Sirsodaya sign" indicates succes. When one is asked a question like "Should I sell my flat" then the Sirsodaya sign rising indicates succes in that undertaking of selling ones flat. But I was not asked "should I sell the flat" but "do we have to sell our flat".
With such question I am confused how to apply the succes and failure indications. Does the indication like Sirsodaya sign rising indicate succes when the question is do we have to sell our flat or contrary? Does the succes indications mean "Yes you have to sell your flat" which would mean something negative for the person who asked and is actually a failure for them or does the succes indication mean "No, you dont have to sell your flat" which means something positive for the person and a succes.
I hope I could explain what I want to know properly.
Kind regards
Naro
there is no should or have to, there is only, what do we do in prasna. So if the chart indicates a sale, it means they sell it, should or have to, those are ideas of a wounded mind and have no place in astrology.
in a case where there is any ambiguity about the question, you have to just read the chart. Read to see what yogas are coming into being and predict the future for those things. Then look at the 11th, if the 11th house is connected to first as per the success rules in which case the deeper meaning of what they really want will happen in time.
@ernst Thank you for the quick reply.
"there is no should or have to, there is only, what do we do in prasna. So if the chart indicates a sale, it means they sell it, should or have to, those are ideas of a wounded mind and have no place in astrology. "
>>Could you elaborate on that. What you mean there is no place for should or have to? I mean we have to use some words to formulate the question. I often ask if I should do something, meaning I want to know if that is good if I do whatever it is. How otherwise one should ask a question? Is a proper question then something like "Will I sell this flat?". But then where is the free will? As I have heard that when there is a difference in a theme of ones live from the natal chart and a Prasna about that topic that the natal chart may indicate what if destined and Prasna may indicate one free will. Free will and how it applies is a longer and more complex topic and these few sentences does no justice to the topic.
"in a case where there is any ambiguity about the question, you have to just read the chart. Read to see what yogas are coming into being and predict the future for those things. Then look at the 11th, if the 11th house is connected to first as per the success rules in which case the deeper meaning of what they really want will happen in time."
>>Thats good advice. Thank you. Reading the chart means to see like if one looks at a normal chart if there is prosperity or positivity for a theme and the outcome will be good or to the contrary. If the contrary then one can say that in regards to that flat there will be no positive results. Correct? In that Prasna there seems to me that the 4th house/Lord are afflicted and there is no connection between Lagna/Lord or 11th Lord and therefore it does not seem to be good for the future of that flat.
The prasna is not a parent to tell a person what to do. It just shows what they WILL do. What will happen. So when they ask, shoudl i do this? YOu look, and if it shows that th ey will do it, you say, you will do it. Then you look at the details and figure out the repercussions of doing it and say you will do it and this is the repercussions, or you will not do it and instead do this and have these repercussions. Then the person can decide if they should or shouldnt do it based on those repercussions. They need to be responsible for it as only they can weight the price they will pay to do something.
That's so weird and paradoxical.
Thats why I don't get the point of consulting the gods in prashna other than to find a lost object.